nav-icons nav-icons
Progress in Political Economy (PPE) Progress in Political Economy (PPE)
LOGIN REGISTER
LOGIN
REGISTER
linklink
  • Home
  • About
  • Manchester University Press Book Series
  • Past & Present Reading Group
  • A Political Economy of Australian Capitalism
  • Journal of Australian Political Economy (JAPE)
    • Journal of Australian Political Economy (JAPE)
    • JAPE Issues
    • JAPE Submission Guidelines
    • JAPE Young Scholar Award
  • Australian IPE Network (AIPEN)
  • Forums
    • Forums
    • Debating Anatomies of Revolution
    • Debating Debtfare States
    • Debating Economic Ideas in Political Time
    • Debating Mass Strikes and Social Movements in Brazil and India
    • Debating Social Movements in Latin America
    • Debating The Making of Modern Finance
    • Debating War and Social Change in Modern Europe
    • Feminist Global “Secureconomy”
    • Gendered Circuits of Labour and Violence in Global Crises
    • Scandalous Economics
    • The Military Roots of Neoliberal Governance
    • Politicising artistic pedagogies
  • Literary Geographies of Political Economy
  • Pedagogy
    • Five Minute Honours Theses
    • Piketty Forum
    • Radical Economics Pedagogy
    • Unconventional Wisdom
    • Journal Club
    • Marxism Reading Group
  • Wheelwright Lecture
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • Links
    • Political Economy At Sydney
    • PHD in Political Economy
    • Master of Political Economy
    • Centre for Future Work
    • Centre for the Study of Social and Global Justice (CSSGJ)
    • Climate Justice Research Centre (UTS)
Antonio Gramsci, 'I Hate New Year's Day'
Previous
Global Labour Studies: Opening the Field to a New Generation of Students
Next

Class Acts: Essays in the Political Economy of Australian Capitalism, Volume 3

by Joe Collins on January 4, 2018

Class Acts: Essays in the Political Economy of Australian Capitalism, Volume 3

Joe Collins | January 4, 2018

Tags: capitalism
capitalism
| 0 456

The overriding commonality underpinning the third volume in the series of five volumes of Essays in the Political Economy of Australian Capitalism is the context of gender, race, and imperialism with the latter addressed both in relation to internal colonialism within the country itself towards Aboriginal Australians as well as its own colonial role in Papua New Guinea (PNG). Ken Buckley frames this volume from the outset with a salient question, then and now: ‘class-struggle is a vital concept, but what is class?’

Buckley’s introduction contains a clear and conscious articulation of the intersection of class contexts with race and gender. In the text itself this commences with an essay on the structure of feeling—drawing from E.P. Thompson—of class-consciousness to address the segmentation of the labour market in Australia along gender lines, especially women’s unpaid labour in the household. In Bettina Cass’s own words, drawing from Mariarosa Dalla Costa, among others, ‘Women’s unpaid domestic labour supports, like an infrastructure, the wage-structures and profits of the industrial-capitalist economy’. Further analysis is then offered in an examination of the segmentation of the labour market through a focus on the racialised conditions of class with reference to migrant labour (John Collins) and the ideology of racism and sexism projected through Italian anti-Fascist struggles in Australia resulting from post-1945 shifts in migration to the country (Gianfranco Cresiani). The conditions of Australia’s role as ‘a late and little imperialist’ power in PNG are then considered and how this was conducted through a colonial regulation of wage labour (Peter Fitzpatrick). The applicability of a theory of internal colonialism is then examined in its relevance to Australian Aborigines as a framework for analysis of the intersections of class with race (Marvyn Hartwig). The arguments in Arghiri Emmanuel’s Unequal Exchange: A Study of the Imperialism of Trade (1972) are then turned to in order to examine the contradictions of unequal exchange between Britain and Australia (David Clark). Finally, the volume closes with chapters on culture (Ian Turner) and education (Helen Palmer) in class contexts situating developments in Australia within a broader social and political context.

Buckley gives a nod in his introduction to Maurice Dobb’s Studies in the Development of Capitalism (1946) to lament that ‘there is no comparable, incisive analysis of the development of Australian capitalism’. That leaves an open question as to whether there is there still a gap for an expansive historical sociology and political economy treatment of the birth of the Australian colonies and “The Australian Road to Capitalism”.

Buckley’s introduction is dated July 1977. This may have permitted the author time to have read Raewyn Connell’s seminal contribution to Australian political economy Ruling Class, Ruling Culture, published 5 months earlier. Had this been the case, Connell’s incisive critical survey of approaches to class analysis in Australia would have highlighted the road map of Australian historiography to which the contributions in this volume added depth. Key to Connell’s critique of class analysis is the distinction between categorical and generative approaches. Categorical analysis belongs to the Weberians and statisticians whilst ‘Marxism of Marx’s kind’ remains, according to Connell, the best example of generative class analysis. Perhaps the reason Marx could muster no more than 5 paragraphs on class in Capital is because he was preoccupied with understanding the internal dynamics of the capitalist mode of production that generated classes. The contributors to this volume build upon attempts in the previous volumes to grasp the contemporary dynamics of capitalism in Australia as a means to generate a theory of class adequate to the task of abolishing class society.

Share this post

  • Tweet
  • Share Post:

Author: Joe Collins

Joe Collins is a Lecturer in the Department of Political Economy at the University of Sydney and completed his PhD at Western Sydney University in 2016. His research offers a historical materialist critique of mineral-rent theory grounded in the historical development of the minerals industry and landed property in Australia.

Related Posts

 

Peter Thiel’s Zero to One explains why ‘big tech’ dominates

Peter Thiel is many things. A staunch libertarian, he is the billionaire Founder of PayPal and Palintir, an early investor in Facebook, and confidant to the likes of Elon Musk a...

 

The End of Capitalism: Ooh La La

Run the Jewels dropped a video for their new single “Ooh La La” on April 27th, 2020, and in the days since I’ve watched and rewatched the video more than 16 times, not cou...

 

Call for Papers – The Spectre of Capitalism in International Studies (EISA 2019)

The Spectre of Capitalism in International Studies (Section 43)

Call for papers for the 13th Pan-European Conference on International Relations, 11–14 Septembe...

 

Is capitalism associated with different forms of exploitation?

In his book Theory As History, Jairus Banaji makes the claim that we should not reduce a particular mode of production to one specific form of exploitation, such as th...

Comments

Leave a Response Cancel reply


Join our mailing list

© Progress in Political Economy (PPE)

Privacy | Designed by Nucleo | Terms and Conditions

  • Home
  • About
  • Manchester University Press Book Series
  • Past & Present Reading Group
  • A Political Economy of Australian Capitalism
  • Journal of Australian Political Economy (JAPE)
    • Journal of Australian Political Economy (JAPE)
    • JAPE Issues
    • JAPE Submission Guidelines
    • JAPE Young Scholar Award
  • Australian IPE Network (AIPEN)
  • Forums
    • Forums
    • Debating Anatomies of Revolution
    • Debating Debtfare States
    • Debating Economic Ideas in Political Time
    • Debating Mass Strikes and Social Movements in Brazil and India
    • Debating Social Movements in Latin America
    • Debating The Making of Modern Finance
    • Debating War and Social Change in Modern Europe
    • Feminist Global “Secureconomy”
    • Gendered Circuits of Labour and Violence in Global Crises
    • Scandalous Economics
    • The Military Roots of Neoliberal Governance
    • Politicising artistic pedagogies
  • Literary Geographies of Political Economy
  • Pedagogy
    • Five Minute Honours Theses
    • Piketty Forum
    • Radical Economics Pedagogy
    • Unconventional Wisdom
    • Journal Club
    • Marxism Reading Group
  • Wheelwright Lecture
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • Links
    • Political Economy At Sydney
    • PHD in Political Economy
    • Master of Political Economy
    • Centre for Future Work
    • Centre for the Study of Social and Global Justice (CSSGJ)
    • Climate Justice Research Centre (UTS)
 

Loading Comments...